----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
@MSGID: 2:5001/100@fidonet 6a94733d
@REPLY: 2:5075/21@fidonet 7d725da7
@CHRS: CP850 2
@TZUTC: 0000
@PID: FidoMail fb9bc36
Hello Dmitry!
In a message of 30 Aug 26 12:39, Dmitry wrote to Dmitry:
DP>> Have you ever tried to read data from
DP>> https://nodelist.fidonet.cc/?
DL> This is actually why I think the question of authority matters more
DL> than the particular representation.
DL> If the nodelist is the source of truth, everything else can be
DL> generated, cached, indexed or presented however we like.
Thank you for spending your time explaining your opinion in great detail!!
The problem is that fixing an untuned piano on a sinking Titanic is a very
important task, yet it`s not the most urgent and probably only a piano tuner is
interested in it.
Let me explain current nodelist state and it`s recent history:
we have 964 hostnames, 60 IP addresses and 4 entries had previously changed IP
to hostname or vice versa and 11 nodes had both hostname and IP address.
Out of those 11 nodes only "s0t.ru" has problems with DNS resolution during the
last 10 months. 10 nodes had no issues at all, IP address was not needed.
So the proposed solution (IP + hostname) could potentially save only one SysOp.
And if his DNS infrastructure is so fragile, he could do the most obvious fix -
add a second hostname on any DDNS service available from Russia with low TTL.
And it`s not uncommon - 11 nodes have multiple hostnames, some from DDNS
services.
As for real problems we need to solve:
135 hostnames in nodelist represent nodes that can`t be accessed for more than
10 months, 45 of them never resolved to anything. No one is fixing them,
75 nodes have IP addresses, 20 of them never answered in the last 10 months.
This is what we should care about - the nodelist has _incorrect_information_,
it`s full of nodes with no connectivity at all (PSTN situation is another sad
story).
By creating DNS based services based on false information people just increase
chaos, they are fixing problems which have no influence over the whole picture.
What I see as a potential project - is to create a nodelist and if someone wants
- a DNS service which will contain real, proven information. Only nodes which
could be reached! Even potentially.
Because it makes zero (!) sense to try to connect to a node that`s been dead for
years via an IP address obtained from binkp.net or fidonet.net. It`s just a
waste of time and human resources debugging potential connection issues for
every SysOp who doesn`t realize the node is long dead.
See you,
dp.
--- FidoMail v0.1.3-71-gfb9bc36
* Origin: livin` on the edge (2:5001/100)
SEEN-BY: 5001/100 5015/46 5020/715 1146 4441 5030/1081 5051/44 5053/58
@PATH: 5001/100 5020/715